Introduction

Imagine you took a wrong turn on your way to the mall and ended up in a 1970s cult instead. Spoiler alert: there’s no Cinnabon here. Welcome to The Church in the Darkness, where you’ll be stealthing your way through a tangled web of allegiances and beliefs trying to find your lost nephew while questioning every life choice that led you here. Strap in, because this ride is as enlightening as it is maddening.

Gameplay

Here's the deal with The Church in the Darkness: you play as Vic, an ex-cop who’s about as subtle as a bull in a china shop. Your mission? Infiltrate a cult called ‘Freedom Town.’ It’s basically a socialist commune gone rogue, led by the charismatic Isaac and Rebecca Walker who think they've got it all figured out, but spoiler alert: they do not. The gameplay is essentially an exercise in stealth and patience, which is harder than it sounds when most of the inhabitants have some pretty gnarly opinions on outsiders. Weirdly enough, their daily sermons sound suspiciously like motivational speeches you'd hear at a team-building retreat except much creepier. You’ll need a combination of skills to thrive here: stealth is your best friend, and if you possess the magical ability to blend into bushes like a chameleon, you’ll want to flaunt that like it’s your secret power. Think of it as an extreme game of hide and seek, but instead of playing with friends, you’re dodging potentially cultish armed guards, and the stakes are higher than your average game night. Sure, you could go in guns blazing (though it's really not advisable)—but where's the fun in that? Timing movement, reading the environment, and knowing when to be a shadow in the night are all crucial to getting in and out without drawing attention. Oh, and did I mention that the layout of the camp changes each time you play? Yes, the game has a procedural generation aspect, making sure that every playthrough feels fresh and yet infuriatingly unpredictable. Along the way, you’ll collect intel about the cult, interact with its quirky inhabitants, and essentially make the difficult decision—do you save Alex or just take a few selfies with the sugar-coated indoctrination that’s happening around you? The choice is yours, but good luck trying to prevent the tension from building like a soap opera cliffhanger every time you hear Isaac's calming voice blaring from the PA system. Not to mention, you'll feel the fear of being discovered creeping up your spine like your childhood nightmares.

Graphics

Let's get it out of the way: graphically, The Church in the Darkness won't set your PS4 on fire, but it's not abhorrent either. The visuals are reminiscent of a slightly janky late '90s adventure game—think of those old-school vibes but with a 21st-century polish. The stylized environment fits the theme beautifully, immersing players in the eeriness of this secluded commune. Each character has enough personality to keep things interesting—it's like watching your favorite character actors get over-the-top with their performances in a weird indie film. Light and shadows play a pivotal role here, and you'll find yourself ducking behind trees, hiding in bushes, and generally making connections to your own life skills at your local park (yes, practice makes perfect, friends!).

Conclusion

In the end, The Church in the Darkness has a lot of promise but struggles to deliver a consistent experience. It’s a game full of intrigue, captivating story potential, and a touch of existential dread, all wrapped up in a solid concept. Stealth gameplay and procedural generation add layers to this cult-crawling adventure, but with a frustrating level of challenge that might leave you throwing your controller across the room more often than you'd like. With that said, if you're into infiltrating a cult (who isn't?), getting existentially reflective about your life choices, and basically playing hide-and-seek with a bunch of slightly unstable commune members, then dive right in! Just remember, whether you steal candy from a baby or don’t come back from the deep, dark recesses of cult life, sometimes it’s better not to know what goes on in the metaphorical woods. A solid pick for fans of stealth puzzles, but probably best enjoyed in small doses. Give it a shot, and you may find the challenges as thrilling as they are unnerving.

See Latest Prices for The Church in the Darkness on PS4 on Amazon