Introduction

Madden NFL 25 has hit the virtual gridiron, attempting to take the football gaming series to new heights while also managing not to trip over the same obstacles as its predecessors. Published by EA Sports and boasting the Frostbite engine under the hood, this entry aims to breathe fresh air into an aging franchise. But does it succeed, or is it just another wait-and-see moment in the long history of 'it’s your turn, buddy'? Let's strap on our cleats and hit the field to find out.

Gameplay

In terms of gameplay, Madden NFL 25 feels like that one friend who shows up late to the party but still expects a raving welcome. The on-field action is a delightful mix of rookie mistakes and expert plays—exactly like a typical Sunday afternoon game. The Controls are pretty much read-out-loud from a manual written in Ancient Greek: they make sense once you get the hang of it, but until then, you might be left feeling a bit confused as you accidentally throw a pass to the wrong team because your thumb slipped. The mechanics have undergone some tweaks with ball physics that claim to mimic actual gameplay. Spoiler alert: it sometimes does that and sometimes looks like a goose trying to fly. Watching a ball tumble through the air often feels more like a circus show than an NFL game. One of the touted additions is the Franchise mode. It’s back, and this time it still feels like a questionable sequel to a sequel—familiar, but only slightly improved. There’s still a wealth of options to run your team (or wreck it) as you make trades, sign agents, and—if you’re unlucky—watch players go inactive due to a variety of baffling injuries like ‘mild sprain to pride’. Multiplayer has received some love with online matchups and competitive features for those who think they’re better than everyone else. Yet there’s always that one guy who brings his custom team and ruins the game, much like that one uncle who gets way too competitive over a friendly family board game; we’ve all been there.

Graphics

Graphics are one area where Madden NFL 25 shines like a brand-new shiny helmet—especially on the PS5. Playing in the enhanced Frostbite engine really helps the visuals pop, with lifelike animations that can make you question whether you're still in a video game or perhaps watching an actual NFL game. The sweat drops feel real, the grass has never looked greener, and the crowd—those pixelated fans—look a tad more lifelike than they did in the last iteration, so we’re making progress here! The lighting effects can make a great football field glow beautifully under the stadium lights, while the sidelines can look as empty as a college literature class on a Friday. The character models, especially the players, have seen a significant upgrade, allowing for nuanced expressions that can range from the confidence of a quarterback discussing his latest shoe deal to the sheer terror of a lineman facing a blitz (ew, no thank you). But let’s be real, there are still moments that remind you this is a game. The awkward animations have not disappeared entirely—watching a wide receiver juke in slow motion is as captivating as it sounds, and by ‘captivating,’ I mean you’ll probably chuckle a bit.

Conclusion

Madden NFL 25 tries valiantly to satisfy both the hard-core fan and the casual gamer, but like that giant burrito you ate before a night out, it can leave you feeling a bit uneven. There are plenty of improvements, but it’s almost like EA decided to throw on a shiny new coat of paint without making sure the walls were even structurally sound. Franchise mode feels like it’s recovering from a breakup—it’s better, but still definitely needs some therapy. For anyone deeply invested in the Madden franchise, this game will provide ample gameplay to enjoy, as long as you’re not expecting a complete overhaul. New players might find themselves fumbled by some familiar pitfalls. Overall, Madden NFL 25 earns a solid 6.5 out of 10—not a game-changer, but worth a toss if you’re looking for some fun on the virtual field. Just remember: in Madden, as in life, sometimes you’ve got to go for that Hail Mary, even if you don’t know the playbook!

See Latest Prices for Madden NFL 25 on PS5 on Amazon