In a world where mysteries are commonplace and overly dramatic characters abound, Agatha Christie: The ABC Murders attempts to wrangle Hercule Poirot into your Nintendo DS. And while this detective story tries hard to hit the crime-solving nail on the head, it might just find itself with a self-inflicted wound more befitting of its Victorian setting. Buckle up, this review will dig into every nook and cranny of the game, so grab your magnifying glass and let's go sleuthing, shall we?
Gameplay centers around Hercule Poirot and his companion Captain Hastings as they navigate crime scenes and interrogate suspects. It's essentially a point-and-click adventure, which means that if you've ever tried to solve a mystery in your room while waiting for mom to finish cooking dinner, you're halfway there. The twist? This game offers a unique option to have a different murderer each playthrough, altering clues and testimonies like a game of detective Russian roulette. Wonderful idea, right? Well, let's just say that while the prospect is intriguing, the execution feels as clumsy as Poirot trying to do the cha-cha. Players will find that each scene is relatively sparse, often requiring a fair amount of pixel-hunting to discover vital clues. As for the puzzles? They range from
Visually, imagine if the cardboard cutouts from a school play decided to embark on a three-dimensional adventure. The graphics feel rather dull and uninspired, reminiscent of a high-school art project that didn't get past the concept stage. Characters move about as if they're being operated by marionette strings - giving life a whole new meaning in the world of video game motion. Additionally, due to the DS's hardware limitations, animations fall short in fluidity. The only saving grace? The game attempts to stay true to Christie's character designs and Victorian aesthetics, but they lack that extra zing you'd want from a murder mystery that should dazzle and intrigue.
The ABC Murders on the Nintendo DS is like a tepid cup of Earl Grey: a nice thought, but ultimately disappointing. With lackluster graphics, forgettable puzzles, and a narrative that doesn't pack the punch it should, this game serves as a stark reminder that a great character doesn't always guarantee a great game. It's okay for die-hard Agatha Christie fans who want to take a stab at the classics, but if you're looking for a solid, immersive experience, you'd be better off just reading the book (and using your imagination, god forbid). Thus, it lands a mediocre score that mirrors its own execution: a 5 out of 10, which means there's still a pulse, but it's definitely not thriving. Detective work can be hard, but it doesn't have to be boring-bring back the fun or risk being left to gather dust in the bargain bin.