Gamefings logoimg

Review of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on PS5

by Max Rathon Max Rathon photo Nov 2021
Cover image of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on PS5
Gamefings Score: 7
Platform: PS5 PS5 logo
Released: 16 Nov 2021
Genre: Action-Adventure
Developer: Frogwares
Publisher: Frogwares

Introduction

Ah, the great detective Sherlock Holmes is back and this time, he's in his twenties and possibly still figuring out how to tie his own cravat. Mysterious conspiracies are afoot, and it's up to you (yes, you in pajamas with snacks) to solve them all in 'Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One.' From Frogwares, this isn't just a whodunit, it's more like a 'who-dunnit-and-why-should-I-care!' set in an open-world that might look a little too 'vacant' at times. Buckle your seatbelts, or at least adjust them, because we're diving into the Mediterranean sun without sunscreen on this one.

Gameplay

In 'Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One,' you step into the shoes of a young Sherlock who's trying to juggle mourning his mom, solving murders, and making dubious life choices-because who hasn't had a moment of existential dread at the ripe age of 21? The game tackles complex investigations, blending classic detective gameplay with new-age open-world mechanics. You can pick up just about anything on the ground (or off of other people), aren't you the little scavenger? The investigations are engaging, featuring some rather clever puzzles that would make even Inspector Gadget tap his head in admiration. But prepare yourself for some finely tuned frustration as you jog from one messy end of town to the other, questioning suspects who clearly don't have a clue what day it is. Open world? More like *open endless running through the mundane*, am I right? At least the scenery is picturesque, even if the NPCs look as lively as wallflowers in a dark corner of the dance floor.

Graphics

Visually, it's a true gem on the PS5, with Unreal Engine 4 doing its magic but occasionally forgetting to polish a few edges. The art style is reminiscent of a storybook, hinting at a world filled with intrigue but occasionally reminiscent of a school play with costumes that don't quite fit. Buildings feel alive, shadows dance, and the lighting, oh, it ebbs and flows like Sherlock's confidence. Unfortunately, one might experience pop-in textures or frame drops that leave you feeling like you're trudging through glue at times-dare I say it could use a bit more QA love? If the game were a sandwich, the graphics would be artisanal bread with high-quality fillings, but a few ingredients feel a bit stale. Seriously, someone needs to check the expiration date on those shadows!

Conclusion

'Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One' is a well-crafted experience that flirts with genius, yet sometimes stumbles like a toddler trying to play hopscotch on a tightrope. When the dust settles, it's evident that the engaging detective mechanics shine bright against the dull backdrop of its open world. If you're a fan of mysteries or simply enjoy eavesdropping on other people's business while trying to piece together who drank the last of the milk in your fridge, this might just tickle your fancy. Sit down with some tea (or whatever you fancy), let Sherlock guide you, and unravel the primal mysteries of Cordona. Just remember: don't chase shadows unless you're sure they aren't just your own!

See Latest Prices for Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on PS5 on Amazon

See Prices for Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on PS5 on Ebay

Related
Latest
image for news article 'Sophie Turner Is Lara Croft — How Tomb Raider's Brutal Skill Ceiling Will Shape Amazon's TV Take'
Hemal Harris - 04 Sep 2025
Sophie Turner will play Lara Croft in Amazon's Tomb Raider series. Here's how the show can capture the games' brutal challenge loo...
image for news article 'Gamescom 2025: From Hornet's Revenge to Gunfights in the Future — The Biggest Reveals, Ranked by Hype (and Probability of Screaming)'
Gemma Looksby - 27 Aug 2025
Gamescom 2025 unleashed release dates, surprises, and enough nostalgia to power a retro arcade. Hollow Knight: Silksong finally la...
image for news article 'From Sidekick to Symptom: An In-Depth Look at How Game Characters Grow (and Break) Over Time'
Tanya Krane - 22 Aug 2025
A witty, in-depth analysis of how video game characters evolve - from antiheroes and companions to tragic villains - and how gamep...
image for news article 'Helldivers 2: The Ultimate Skill Test — How to Survive When Friendly Fire Is A Feature'
Hemal Harris - 22 Aug 2025
Helldivers 2 turns cooperative shooters into a terrifying teamwork exam. From friendly-fire fiascos to stratagem juggling and glob...
image for news article 'PlayStation Plus August Drop: Mortal Kombat 1, Spider-Man, Sword of the Sea and Two Resident Evils — Sony’s Buffet of Beatdowns and Beachside Introspection'
Chucky - 22 Aug 2025
Sony's August PlayStation Plus drop mixes Mortal Kombat 1 and Marvel's Spider-Man with day-one indie Sword of the Sea, EDF6 co-op ...
image for news article 'Tariff Drama and Console Character Arcs: How the PS5 Price Hike Recasts PlayStation's Story'
Tanya Krane - 21 Aug 2025
Sony just raised PS5 prices in the US - but this is more than a number. We break down the cast, the catalyst (hello, tariffs), and...
image for news article 'The Nintendo Switch 2: An Overhyped Second Date That Actually Went Well'
Chucky - 14 Jun 2025
Nintendo Switch 2 has hit the market, and it's selling like hotcakes! Here's what you need to know about this slightly improved se...