Gamefings logoimg

Review of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on Xbox Series X/S

by Jay Aborro Jay Aborro photo Nov 2021
Cover image of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on Xbox Series X/S
Gamefings Score: 7.5
Released: 16 Nov 2021
Genre: Action-Adventure
Developer: Frogwares
Publisher: Frogwares

Introduction

Step back into the roaring 1880s with Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One, where our favorite pipe-smoking detective is young, troubled, and sporting a wardrobe that says 'I may solve mysteries, but I also appreciate a good cape.' This charming little game is packed with intrigue, conspiracy, and it's got more plot twists than a pretzel factory. Grab your magnifying glass, because we're diving deep into the Mediterranean island of Cordona!

Gameplay

Picture this: you're a 21-year-old Sherlock Holmes, freshly arrived on a sun-soaked island to investigate the death of your mother-no pressure, right? The game plunges you into an open world where you can explore to your heart's content (but let's be honest, pretty much just for the sake of looking for clues). The gameplay combines classic detective work with some action-adventure elements, meaning you'll get to whip out your inner sleuth by interrogating locals, stealing glances at suspicious writings, and piecing together quite the engaging mystery. But beware-the open world can feel a little... well, empty. Like a college dorm fridge at the end of the semester, it might just leave you feeling unsatisfied if you're not looking closely. Still, the detective mechanics are solid, and the game's mechanics encourage strategic reasoning, ensuring that the journey to solve the ultimate mystery is thorough and occasionally witty.

Graphics

Rendered through Unreal Engine 4, the visuals pop with vibrant colors and the charm of the 1880s! The characters are recognizable, albeit a touch exaggerated, which works well with the narrative's sometimes whimsical tone. The environment of Cordona is beautiful-even if at times it feels like there's no one around to appreciate it. Watch out for some technical hiccups, though; it can be as if the graphics took a few too many cues from the slow motion of a poorly animated sitcom. Still, when everything runs smoothly, it's a picturesque setting ripe for high-stakes drama and low-key snooping.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on the Xbox Series X/S is a solid entry into the detective genre. It serves up a combination of engaging mystery mechanics wrapped up in a gorgeous albeit somewhat sparse open world. While it may buckle under the weight of its ambitions at times, it's still an enjoyable romp through Holmes' formative years. The game won't quite rival the likes of your favorite blockbuster titles, but if you've ever thought, 'You know, I could use a little more existential dread with my literature', then it's time to put on your deerstalker hat and dive into the sea of intrigue. Now, if only Watson could make an appearance in this epic origin story...

See Latest Prices for Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on Xbox Series X/S on Amazon

See Prices for Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One on Xbox Series X/S on Ebay

Related
Latest
image for news article 'Sophie Turner Is Lara Croft — How Tomb Raider's Brutal Skill Ceiling Will Shape Amazon's TV Take'
Hemal Harris - 04 Sep 2025
Sophie Turner will play Lara Croft in Amazon's Tomb Raider series. Here's how the show can capture the games' brutal challenge loo...
image for news article 'Gamescom 2025: From Hornet's Revenge to Gunfights in the Future — The Biggest Reveals, Ranked by Hype (and Probability of Screaming)'
Gemma Looksby - 27 Aug 2025
Gamescom 2025 unleashed release dates, surprises, and enough nostalgia to power a retro arcade. Hollow Knight: Silksong finally la...
image for news article 'From Sidekick to Symptom: An In-Depth Look at How Game Characters Grow (and Break) Over Time'
Tanya Krane - 22 Aug 2025
A witty, in-depth analysis of how video game characters evolve - from antiheroes and companions to tragic villains - and how gamep...
image for news article 'Helldivers 2: The Ultimate Skill Test — How to Survive When Friendly Fire Is A Feature'
Hemal Harris - 22 Aug 2025
Helldivers 2 turns cooperative shooters into a terrifying teamwork exam. From friendly-fire fiascos to stratagem juggling and glob...
image for news article 'PlayStation Plus August Drop: Mortal Kombat 1, Spider-Man, Sword of the Sea and Two Resident Evils — Sony’s Buffet of Beatdowns and Beachside Introspection'
Chucky - 22 Aug 2025
Sony's August PlayStation Plus drop mixes Mortal Kombat 1 and Marvel's Spider-Man with day-one indie Sword of the Sea, EDF6 co-op ...
image for news article 'Tariff Drama and Console Character Arcs: How the PS5 Price Hike Recasts PlayStation's Story'
Tanya Krane - 21 Aug 2025
Sony just raised PS5 prices in the US - but this is more than a number. We break down the cast, the catalyst (hello, tariffs), and...
image for news article 'The Nintendo Switch 2: An Overhyped Second Date That Actually Went Well'
Chucky - 14 Jun 2025
Nintendo Switch 2 has hit the market, and it's selling like hotcakes! Here's what you need to know about this slightly improved se...